Edited by the Institute for Social Research, Swinburne University of Technology

Positive not punitive the best approach

  • Chris Sarra

05 October 2009Just getting an Indigenous child inside the school gate does not mean the problem is solved, writes Chris Sarra in The Australian

WHILE THE Family Responsibilities Commission in Queensland may claim it is successful in getting Aboriginal children re-engaged in school, taxpayers have every right to question such claims. In the interest of healthy debate and development of good public policy, there are alternative views I think must be considered. All good business and public policy should be scrutinised within the context of the triple bottom line. Policy must deliver on economic, environmental and social returns to be considered effective. Against this background I suspect the public has reason to be outraged.

The FRC is an independent statutory body that includes representatives from four Cape York communities (Aurukun, Coen, Mossman Gorge and Hope Vale) taking part in four-year welfare reform trials.

From the outset I acknowledge the good intention of this strategy. I like the part of the FRC's design that engages indigenous elders in decision-making relating to school attendance. It is absolutely crucial that Aboriginal children engage positively with school. But I do not share the excitement of some about the attendance results trumpeted this week and, like many, have some questions. It is welcome that in three of the four schools involved in an FRC trial there is some improvement. But, for the dollars spent, they should all be exceptional...

Read the full article

Chris Sarra is executive director of the Indigenous Education Leadership Institute at Queensland University of Technology.

Photo: Susan Stewart/ iStockphoto

Events

Conference
24 Mar 2010 - 9:00am - 25 Mar 2010 - 5:30am
Darwin
Conference
25 Mar 2010 - 9:00am - 26 Mar 2010 - 5:00pm
Canberra

Noticeboard

16 February 2010

RMIT University in Melbourne runs a degree program where groups of
communication research‐trained students work on a communication research
project for a not‐for‐profit client.

14 January 2010

The National Prison Book Program provides prisoners with free reading materials. Our aim is to provide books to prisoners and enhance prison library and educational services.

27 May 2009

The National Human Rights Online Consultation on Open Forum will run from 19 May until 26 June 2009, providing an extended opportunity for the Australian community to share their views about which rights and responsibilities matter to us as a society,