Why "league tables" of schools are a failure

21 August 2009It is the sloppy thinking that fails to distinguish between "underperforming" schools and "disadvantaged" schools, writes Ian Keese on On Line Opinion

THOSE WHO support publishing “league tables” that rank schools by results often take the high moral ground by arguing that to do so is in the interests of the disadvantaged students and that teachers only oppose them so they can hide their failures.

For instance, on 13 August the Australian reported that “Julia Gillard is to crash through opposition to publication of data on school performance, insisting that the move will allow her to target underperforming schools with extra resources” and she “dismissed complaints that the data would lead to the production of simplistic league tables”. In fact what Julia Gillard said in her speech the day before was far more measured...

Read the full article

Photo: Susan Stewart/ iStockphoto.com

 

Related Topics

Education

Economics

Social Policy

Related content

Most viewed: This week

1
Gender and corporate social responsibility: it’s a matter of sustainability
2
Northern Territory Emergency Response: Report of the NTER Review Board
3
The governance of sustainability: how companies manage their corporate responsibilities
4
Can cultural differences affect access of families to health care?
5
Students as learning designers: using social media to scaffold the experience

Jobs

Associate
Grattan Institute
Melbourne
Principal Evaluation Officer
Department of Communities
Brisbane
Dean of Media and Communication
Melbourne

Events

Workshop
Electronic Document and Records Management
14 Feb 2012 - 15 Feb 2012
Sydney
Conference
Conference: 'Is social democracy exhausted? Pathways, reflections, dilemmas'
17 Feb 2012 - 9:00am - 18 Feb 2012 - 5:30pm
Adelaide
Workshop
Leading the way in Internal Communications
21 Feb 2012 - 23 Feb 2012
Rydges, Melbourne

Noticeboard

Access and equity inquiry
20 December 2011

On 18 November 2011, Parliamentary Secretary for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Senator the Hon Kate Lundy, announced the establishment of an independent panel of eminent community leaders to conduct an inquiry into Australian Government services to ensure they are responsive to the needs of Australians from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds.

Centre for Sustainability Leadership - 2012 Fellowship Program
02 December 2011

Applications are now open for a unique training opportunity for selected individuals develop the skills, networks and knowledge needed to be effective in forging a more sustainable future.

New research to look at children with disability entering state care
15 November 2011

The Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission is researching the issue of families relinquishing children with disability into state care. This follows concerns raised by the Commission’s Disability Reference Group, which indicate that families are surrendering their children because they are not given enough support to continue full-time caring.

Topics

APO