Refecting international patterns, Aboriginal people in Victoria are more likely to gamble and to experience gambling harm than non-Indigenous Victorians. This paper describes experiences of gambling reported by 50 Aboriginal people interviewed in regional Victoria in 2016 and 2017 as part of studies initiated by two Aboriginal community-controlled organisations. Data were analysed using social practice theory (SPT) and coded to the elements of ‘meaning’, ‘material’, ‘competence’, and ‘temporality’. Across each element we identifed highly contradictory experiences. Gambling held meaning as an opportunity for community gatherings but was also regarded as a cause of domestic violence, confict, isolation and shame. Materially, the venues that ofered gambling were experienced by many Aboriginal people as safe and welcoming, but at the same time gambling produced a damaging afective sense of addiction for some. Gambling was a competency that some people valued and taught to children, but it was also seen as undermining cultural practices. While Aboriginal people were historically denied access to licensed venues ofering commercial gambling, many participants now found opportunities to gamble inescapable. The intermingling of benefts and harms described above supports the need for a multi-faceted response to gambling in Aboriginal communities, which includes harm reduction as well as supply restriction and treatment. Some experiences of gambling related by our participants refected those reported also by non-Indigenous Australians, while others were diferently nuanced. Because SPT is used to understand collectively-shared practices, it facilitates the identifcation of gambling interventions at the level of the community, as recommended by our research participants.