Finance Minister Mathias Cormann evoked memories of the Cold War when he said he would characterise Labor's policies as socialist. Later, in a speech, he referred to the Berlin Wall, saying Labor was reverting to the socialism of an earlier era. RMIT ABC Fact Check found Senator Cormann's claim was sensationalist. There is no settled definition of "socialism" or "socialist policies". Socialism is a collection of ideas that have been subject to vigorous debate since the 19th century. One form of socialism is centred around public (i.e. government) ownership of "the means of production, distribution and exchange". The Australian Labor Party's national platform has long included an objective of "democratic socialism" along these lines "to the extent necessary", but it is not reflected in the party's current policies. Labor is not proposing nationalisation of Australian industries. A broader definition of socialism includes policies that use the taxation system to redistribute income and espouse government intervention in the market economy. On that basis, some of Labor's policies are, strictly speaking, "socialist". But Senator Cormann goes too far when he talks of the Berlin Wall and the "system of government" that existed in Eastern Europe between 1945 and 1989. That failed totalitarian and oppressive system bears no resemblance to the policies of Australia's Labor Party.
Verdict: Sensationalist
Fact sheet
Description
Publication Details
Copyright:
Australian Broadcasting Corporation 2017
License type:
All Rights Reserved
Access Rights Type:
open
Post date:
26 May 2020
